When attempting to teach economic principles we always try and determine the objective functions of market participants. In this way, we can predict what individuals are likely to do in certain circumstances.
For example, we assume that firms will attempt to maximize profits, or equivalently minimize costs. From this we can predict how they will behave when faced with rising input prices, rising output prices, the imposition of taxes and government regulations.
Individuals, on the other hand, are assumed to maximize utility, an abstract measure of happiness or satisfaction. From this we can predict how they will behave to changing incomes, prices, tastes and information.
What then, do governments maximize? We would like to believe that they maximize social welfare or economic growth or employment or something along that line. However, evidence seems to suggest that our politicians are actually vote maximizers. They tend to do or say whatever is required to get elected or re-elected. We offer some recent evidence from the state of Kentucky where, in a matter of a few days, they introduced a series of bills that will leave you shaking your head.
The first article (click here) relates to a proposal to make it illegal to smoke in a car where a minor (person under 17) is present.
A second article (click here) reports that Republican representative Lonnie Napier wants all recipients of state funding, including welfare, to be subjected to random drug testing. Those found testing positive for illicit drugs would lose their state benefits. One can't help wondering if this applies to the elected representatives as well. At the same time another bill being introduced reduces the severity of punishment for the possession of illegal drugs (click here). A cynical person would suggest that both measures are simply designed to save money and have nothing to do with the question of illegal drugs.
The third article (click here) relates to a proposal to “exempt Kentucky-made guns and ammunition from federal background checks, dealer licenses and other national regulations if the items remain in the state.” From http://www.lcav.org: “Kentucky does not impose criminal liability for negligent storage of a firearm, even if a child gains access to the firearm and causes an injury or death.” Clearly, at least in Kentucky, cigarettes and welfare recipients on drugs are more dangerous than firearms.
In no way are we critical of the citizens of the fine state of Kentucky. Their politicians are doing exactly what they think the citizens want. The only reason this blog is specific to Kentucky is because all of the articles came out in the same week.
Tuesday, January 18, 2011
Tuesday, January 11, 2011
Debt Loads and Low Interest Rates
There have been several articles appearing in the papers raising alarm at the increasing amount of consumer debt in Canada and other industrialized countries. There is a concern that if, and when, interest rates begin to rise, the cost of servicing the debt will cause hardship among a large percentage of the population. We cannot help but wonder why the growing debt load is a surprise to anyone, except for the Keynesians (or maybe it’s the Kenyans – still working on that one). (See previous blog)
In the Keynesian consumption model, a reduction in disposable income is accompanied by a reduction in both consumer spending and savings. Aggregate spending in the economy decreases and leads us down the path to depression unless the government stimulates the economy with expansionary fiscal policy. Only large decreases in income are expected to cause large increases in debt load.
According to Milton Friedman’s Permanent Income Hypothesis, however, consumption will only be affected to the extent that individuals consider the reduction in incomes to be permanent. If the recession is expected to be temporary, then savings decreases dramatically (or debt increases) to maintain the level of consumption. When the economy rebounds, consumption does not rise. Instead, savings increases and debts are repaid. This is likely what is happening in Canada where we escaped most of the banking crisis. The story in the US is very different where projections suggest that the labour market may not recover for ten years.
There is also a microeconomic model that helps. Here, the basic premise is that a pizza today is worth more than a pizza in the future. For each individual, the difference between the two is known as the rate of time preference. When the interest rate is below the rate of time preference, we are better off by borrowing and consuming now. If the interest rate is higher, then we tend to save. Interest rates are at historically low levels and so we would expect individuals with stable incomes to be borrowing now and repaying later.
Articles:
In the Keynesian consumption model, a reduction in disposable income is accompanied by a reduction in both consumer spending and savings. Aggregate spending in the economy decreases and leads us down the path to depression unless the government stimulates the economy with expansionary fiscal policy. Only large decreases in income are expected to cause large increases in debt load.
According to Milton Friedman’s Permanent Income Hypothesis, however, consumption will only be affected to the extent that individuals consider the reduction in incomes to be permanent. If the recession is expected to be temporary, then savings decreases dramatically (or debt increases) to maintain the level of consumption. When the economy rebounds, consumption does not rise. Instead, savings increases and debts are repaid. This is likely what is happening in Canada where we escaped most of the banking crisis. The story in the US is very different where projections suggest that the labour market may not recover for ten years.
There is also a microeconomic model that helps. Here, the basic premise is that a pizza today is worth more than a pizza in the future. For each individual, the difference between the two is known as the rate of time preference. When the interest rate is below the rate of time preference, we are better off by borrowing and consuming now. If the interest rate is higher, then we tend to save. Interest rates are at historically low levels and so we would expect individuals with stable incomes to be borrowing now and repaying later.
Articles:
Bank of Canada comment in Financial Post
Bloomberg report on Canadian debt relative to US debt
Ottawa Business Journal reporting on comments by the Superintendent of Bankruptcy
Wednesday, January 5, 2011
A World Without Borders
The New York Times published an article that tells of the pending demise of Borders, the US bookseller. (Click here for article) Regular readers of this blog will not be surprised. Last September we told the story of the downfall of Blockbusters, the bricks and mortar rental outlets for movie rentals. (Click here for blog) Blockbusters failed to respect the competition presented by the likes of RedBox and Netfile.
Borders, and other booksellers, failed to respond quickly enough to the introduction of the various e-readers and the electronic delivery of books. Another NY Times article published before the holidays predicted that the number of e-readers could reach 10.3 million by the end of 2010. We are still waiting on Christmas sales numbers. (Click here for article)
The problem for bricks and mortar stores is the opportunity cost of shopping there. I went to 3 different bookstores looking for a particular trade paperback, to no avail. That took 3 hours of my time which, at my tutoring rate, was over $100. That is too much to pay for a paperback. Yesterday, I ordered it from Amazon. $7.99 plus tax and 1 minute of my time. Much cheaper.
News from the electronic trade show in Las Vegas tells us to expect more tablets capable of displaying e-books. Due to increasing returns to scale and new entry, the cost of these devices will fall throughout 2011 and as they do, more people will buy them and the demand for e-books will increase. Barnes and Noble may be next in the US, and we will likely see some restructuring in Canada where Indigo dominates the market through Indigo/Chapters/Coles.
One bookstore that I’m sure will survive however, is Powell’s in Portland Oregon. If you’ve ever been there, you know what I mean. If you haven’t, you don’t know what you’re missing.
Borders, and other booksellers, failed to respond quickly enough to the introduction of the various e-readers and the electronic delivery of books. Another NY Times article published before the holidays predicted that the number of e-readers could reach 10.3 million by the end of 2010. We are still waiting on Christmas sales numbers. (Click here for article)
The problem for bricks and mortar stores is the opportunity cost of shopping there. I went to 3 different bookstores looking for a particular trade paperback, to no avail. That took 3 hours of my time which, at my tutoring rate, was over $100. That is too much to pay for a paperback. Yesterday, I ordered it from Amazon. $7.99 plus tax and 1 minute of my time. Much cheaper.
News from the electronic trade show in Las Vegas tells us to expect more tablets capable of displaying e-books. Due to increasing returns to scale and new entry, the cost of these devices will fall throughout 2011 and as they do, more people will buy them and the demand for e-books will increase. Barnes and Noble may be next in the US, and we will likely see some restructuring in Canada where Indigo dominates the market through Indigo/Chapters/Coles.
One bookstore that I’m sure will survive however, is Powell’s in Portland Oregon. If you’ve ever been there, you know what I mean. If you haven’t, you don’t know what you’re missing.
Sunday, January 2, 2011
A New Year. For Estonia, a new currency.
Yesterday, Estonia became the 17th country to adopt the euro as its currency. Given all the recent turmoil, they may regret the decision before this year is over. We have previously written about the troubles facing the EU and its common currency and since it was one of the biggest stories of 2010 we decided to start this year with an update. (click here for previous post) A Reuters article discusses the reasons why Estonia joined and why other Eastern European countries have not joined. (Click here for article)
Meanwhile, in Slovakia, some are regretting adopting the euro and the Associated Press is reporting that leaders in that country are exploring their options with respect to leaving the common currency. The advantages of the euro once outweighed the disadvantages, but if member countries are forced into bailouts of fiscally irresponsible countries the costs may exceed the benefits. (Click here for article)
We have expressed our thoughts on the future of the euro, and now, a UK based think tank has given the euro a 1 in 5 chance of surviving in its current form in 2020. The prediction is based on the unwillingness of the PIIGS to curtail spending and raise taxes to get their fiscal houses in order. The FANGs (my new acronym for France, Austria, Netherlands and Germany) may not be willing to undertake anymore bailouts for fear of putting their own budgets at risk. (Click here for article)
Of course, German Chancellor Angela Merkel and French President Nicolas Sarkozy in separate New Year's addresses have reiterated their support for the euro. (Click here for German article, and click here for French article). This is to be expected. If either of the two leaders even hinted that they may pull out of the euro and revert to the franc and deutschemark or to a northern european currency, the value of the euro would plummet as speculator sold the currency en masse. The demise of the euro will occur with no warning. One morning we will wake up and it will be a fait accompli.
It will be an interesting year, and a story we will continue to follow.
Meanwhile, in Slovakia, some are regretting adopting the euro and the Associated Press is reporting that leaders in that country are exploring their options with respect to leaving the common currency. The advantages of the euro once outweighed the disadvantages, but if member countries are forced into bailouts of fiscally irresponsible countries the costs may exceed the benefits. (Click here for article)
We have expressed our thoughts on the future of the euro, and now, a UK based think tank has given the euro a 1 in 5 chance of surviving in its current form in 2020. The prediction is based on the unwillingness of the PIIGS to curtail spending and raise taxes to get their fiscal houses in order. The FANGs (my new acronym for France, Austria, Netherlands and Germany) may not be willing to undertake anymore bailouts for fear of putting their own budgets at risk. (Click here for article)
Of course, German Chancellor Angela Merkel and French President Nicolas Sarkozy in separate New Year's addresses have reiterated their support for the euro. (Click here for German article, and click here for French article). This is to be expected. If either of the two leaders even hinted that they may pull out of the euro and revert to the franc and deutschemark or to a northern european currency, the value of the euro would plummet as speculator sold the currency en masse. The demise of the euro will occur with no warning. One morning we will wake up and it will be a fait accompli.
It will be an interesting year, and a story we will continue to follow.
Thursday, December 30, 2010
The Efficiency of Auctions
A Globe and Mail article describing the auction processed used to sell houses in Australia distracted us from our holiday celebrations and hockey tournaments. The article argues that an auction drives prices higher than the ask-offer system commonly used in North America. (Click here for article)
Markets are most efficient when there is a large number of both buyers and sellers all dealing with a homogeneous product. This is typically not true in real estate. Properties are heterogeneous; there is only one seller and multiple buyers. There is also an asymmetric information problem in that the seller knows everything that is wrong with the property and the potential buyer doesn’t. In the North American system, the seller offers the property for sale at a price that is higher than the minimum price they will accept. The potential buyers make offers below the maximum price that they are willing to pay.
Then comes the game. The seller wants to get the highest price that any of the potential buyers would be willing to pay. The seller responds to one of the offers by changing their terms, letting all potential buyers know that there are multiple offers. None of the buyers knows the terms of the other offers. If the sellers can’t come to suitable terms with the first potential buyer, they are free to negotiate with another. Typically, the seller will settle for a price that is less than their initial asking price, and above the initial offer. More importantly, the price will likely be below the highest price that a potential buyer would have been willing to pay. The seller’s agent is supposed to help get the highest price, the buyer’s agent is supposed to help get the lowest possible price. A seller’s agent is considered successful if the property is sold, not if it sold for the maximum price. The marginal benefit to the seller’s agent of getting an extra $1000 for the seller is less than the marginal cost of getting that $1000 and there is no benefit to the buyer’s agent attaining a $1,000 reduction in price. This process is inefficient for both seller and buyer.
An auction works differently. The seller sets a reservation price and multiple buyers bid against each other. The auctioneer is the seller’s agent and works to get the best price possible. As the price rises, potential buyers drop out until two are left. The winning bid will be just above the maximum price of the buyer with the second highest willingness to pay, but below the maximum price that the winning bidder was willing to pay.
The article suggests that the auction process is responsible for the rising prices in the Australian market. People don’t like to lose and therefore bid up prices in a frenzy. This argument requires that bidders behave irrationally on average. We normally assume that individuals maximize utility, or personal welfare. That implies that they know the maximum price that they are willing and able to pay and that rational individuals will not go above this price. An auction increases the price and benefit to the seller, whereas the bid-offer system does not.
Markets are most efficient when there is a large number of both buyers and sellers all dealing with a homogeneous product. This is typically not true in real estate. Properties are heterogeneous; there is only one seller and multiple buyers. There is also an asymmetric information problem in that the seller knows everything that is wrong with the property and the potential buyer doesn’t. In the North American system, the seller offers the property for sale at a price that is higher than the minimum price they will accept. The potential buyers make offers below the maximum price that they are willing to pay.
Then comes the game. The seller wants to get the highest price that any of the potential buyers would be willing to pay. The seller responds to one of the offers by changing their terms, letting all potential buyers know that there are multiple offers. None of the buyers knows the terms of the other offers. If the sellers can’t come to suitable terms with the first potential buyer, they are free to negotiate with another. Typically, the seller will settle for a price that is less than their initial asking price, and above the initial offer. More importantly, the price will likely be below the highest price that a potential buyer would have been willing to pay. The seller’s agent is supposed to help get the highest price, the buyer’s agent is supposed to help get the lowest possible price. A seller’s agent is considered successful if the property is sold, not if it sold for the maximum price. The marginal benefit to the seller’s agent of getting an extra $1000 for the seller is less than the marginal cost of getting that $1000 and there is no benefit to the buyer’s agent attaining a $1,000 reduction in price. This process is inefficient for both seller and buyer.
An auction works differently. The seller sets a reservation price and multiple buyers bid against each other. The auctioneer is the seller’s agent and works to get the best price possible. As the price rises, potential buyers drop out until two are left. The winning bid will be just above the maximum price of the buyer with the second highest willingness to pay, but below the maximum price that the winning bidder was willing to pay.
The article suggests that the auction process is responsible for the rising prices in the Australian market. People don’t like to lose and therefore bid up prices in a frenzy. This argument requires that bidders behave irrationally on average. We normally assume that individuals maximize utility, or personal welfare. That implies that they know the maximum price that they are willing and able to pay and that rational individuals will not go above this price. An auction increases the price and benefit to the seller, whereas the bid-offer system does not.
Wednesday, December 22, 2010
Beating the Market
Yesterday, we quoted a Globe and Mail article that commented on a book Zombie Economics: How Dead Ideas Still Walk Among Us by John Quiggin. (Click here for article). That quote read:
"Nothing in the (efficient market) hypothesis can explain the frequent bubbles and busts, strange stock valuations or the inconvenient truth that some shrewd investors do outperform the market." (emphasis added)
Our previous blog sought to illustrate that a "shrewd investor" could beat the market purely by luck. The evidence of investors outperforming the market is not sufficient to dispell the efficient market hypothesis. Today, we take a stab at what "outperforming the market" means, and what is should mean. By most accounts, beating the market implies creating a portfolio that generates a return, after transaction costs, that exceeds the return of a benchmark index i.e. TSX 60, DJIA, SP500, FTSE 100, CAC40, DAX, Nikkei, Hang Seng, MSWI etc.
There are some problems with this method, however, in that simply comparing the rate of return to a market index does not compensate for the risk of the portfolio. In general, the greater the risk, the greater the return. So, for example, if we create a portolio using only the 30 riskiest stock in the TSX 60, we are likely going to beat the TSX.
There are at least three measures of return that do compensate for risk, and beating the market should be evaluated using one or more of these measures.
The Sharpe measure can be used for sufficiently diversified portfolios and is the ratio of the portolio return minus the risk free rate of return divided by the standard deviation of the portfolio return. This ratio is then compared to the same ratio for the benchmark. The Sharpe measure looks to see if the portfolio lies above or below the capital market line. Above indicates that the porfolio beat the market after compensating for risk.
The Treynor measure can be used for single securities as well as a portfolio and is the the ratio of the portfolio or asset return minus the risk free rate of return divided by the beta of the asset. Beta is a measure of risk relative to the market risk. The Treynor measure looks to see if the portfolio lies above or below the securities market line.
Finally the Jensen measure, or alpha, is similar to the Treynor measure in that is makes a comparison based on beta. Alpha is calculated by taking the difference between the actual rate of return of a portfolio minus the return predicted by the capital asset pricing model (CAPM). If alpha is positive the portfolio beat the market on a risk adjusted basis.
Yesterday, we showed that beating the market can be a matter of pure luck. Today, we showed that beating the market may be a result of taking on excess risk. Our intent is to show that having some shrewd investors that outperform the market is not sufficient to dismiss the EMH.
"Nothing in the (efficient market) hypothesis can explain the frequent bubbles and busts, strange stock valuations or the inconvenient truth that some shrewd investors do outperform the market." (emphasis added)
Our previous blog sought to illustrate that a "shrewd investor" could beat the market purely by luck. The evidence of investors outperforming the market is not sufficient to dispell the efficient market hypothesis. Today, we take a stab at what "outperforming the market" means, and what is should mean. By most accounts, beating the market implies creating a portfolio that generates a return, after transaction costs, that exceeds the return of a benchmark index i.e. TSX 60, DJIA, SP500, FTSE 100, CAC40, DAX, Nikkei, Hang Seng, MSWI etc.
There are some problems with this method, however, in that simply comparing the rate of return to a market index does not compensate for the risk of the portfolio. In general, the greater the risk, the greater the return. So, for example, if we create a portolio using only the 30 riskiest stock in the TSX 60, we are likely going to beat the TSX.
There are at least three measures of return that do compensate for risk, and beating the market should be evaluated using one or more of these measures.
The Sharpe measure can be used for sufficiently diversified portfolios and is the ratio of the portolio return minus the risk free rate of return divided by the standard deviation of the portfolio return. This ratio is then compared to the same ratio for the benchmark. The Sharpe measure looks to see if the portfolio lies above or below the capital market line. Above indicates that the porfolio beat the market after compensating for risk.
The Treynor measure can be used for single securities as well as a portfolio and is the the ratio of the portfolio or asset return minus the risk free rate of return divided by the beta of the asset. Beta is a measure of risk relative to the market risk. The Treynor measure looks to see if the portfolio lies above or below the securities market line.
Finally the Jensen measure, or alpha, is similar to the Treynor measure in that is makes a comparison based on beta. Alpha is calculated by taking the difference between the actual rate of return of a portfolio minus the return predicted by the capital asset pricing model (CAPM). If alpha is positive the portfolio beat the market on a risk adjusted basis.
Yesterday, we showed that beating the market can be a matter of pure luck. Today, we showed that beating the market may be a result of taking on excess risk. Our intent is to show that having some shrewd investors that outperform the market is not sufficient to dismiss the EMH.
Tuesday, December 21, 2010
Probabilities and the Efficient Market Hypothesis
An article in the Globe and Mail got us interested in a book entitled Zombie Economics: How Dead Ideas Still Walk Among Us by John Quiggin. (Click here for article) We currently have the book on order from Amazon and will report back once we have read it in full.
In the meantime, we thought we might do a few blogs on the efficient market hypothesis and this one is based on a single line from the Globe and Mail article that suggests the EMH must be false because:
"Nothing in the hypothesis can explain the frequent bubbles and busts, strange stock valuations or the inconvenient truth that some shrewd investors do outperform the market." (emphasis added)
A little experiment. If you flip a fair coin, what do you believe the likelihood of it coming up 'heads' 10 times in a row? If it did, would you suggest that the coin wasn't balanced properly? Most people would. Now, however, lets start with 1024 people and ask them all to flip a coin. Those that come up tails must leave, and those that come up heads can stay. After the first toss, we should have about 512 people left. Repeat a second time and about 256 people should be left. On each successive toss, about half will be tails and half will be heads. After three tosses 128 people are left, then 64, 32, 16, 8, 4, 2 and finally, after ten rounds, only one person is left. That person just tossed 10 consecutive heads. (The probablility of doing that is one in 1024)
Lets do the experiment again with 1024 "shrewd investors" who build a portfolio by choosing any 59 stocks in the TSX 60. The one stock they don't hold is chosen by throwing a dart at the list. If the stock they omit underperforms the TSX then their portfolio will outperform the market. The omitted stock is chosen at random and thus has a probability of beating the index of approximately one half. After one year, those investors that beat the index can stay, they rest leave. At the beginning of each year, the survivors choose a new portfolio in the same manner. By the same logic as the coin game, after 10 years one of those "shrewd investors" beat the index 10 years in a row ... by throwing a dart.
According to the Chartered Financial Analyst Website, there are currently 90,113 individuals that hold the CFA designation. These are the people that manage portfolios and are well trained in what they do. If they all build portfolios in the game above, 88 will beat the market 10 years in a row, and one will be expected to beat the index for 16 consecutive years.
The existance of investors that outperform the market is not a sufficient reason to dismiss the efficient market hypothesis. As just shown, even with efficient markets, given a big enough pool, it is possible to beat the market entirely by luck.
Next time we look at the meaning of "beating the market".
In the meantime, we thought we might do a few blogs on the efficient market hypothesis and this one is based on a single line from the Globe and Mail article that suggests the EMH must be false because:
"Nothing in the hypothesis can explain the frequent bubbles and busts, strange stock valuations or the inconvenient truth that some shrewd investors do outperform the market." (emphasis added)
A little experiment. If you flip a fair coin, what do you believe the likelihood of it coming up 'heads' 10 times in a row? If it did, would you suggest that the coin wasn't balanced properly? Most people would. Now, however, lets start with 1024 people and ask them all to flip a coin. Those that come up tails must leave, and those that come up heads can stay. After the first toss, we should have about 512 people left. Repeat a second time and about 256 people should be left. On each successive toss, about half will be tails and half will be heads. After three tosses 128 people are left, then 64, 32, 16, 8, 4, 2 and finally, after ten rounds, only one person is left. That person just tossed 10 consecutive heads. (The probablility of doing that is one in 1024)
Lets do the experiment again with 1024 "shrewd investors" who build a portfolio by choosing any 59 stocks in the TSX 60. The one stock they don't hold is chosen by throwing a dart at the list. If the stock they omit underperforms the TSX then their portfolio will outperform the market. The omitted stock is chosen at random and thus has a probability of beating the index of approximately one half. After one year, those investors that beat the index can stay, they rest leave. At the beginning of each year, the survivors choose a new portfolio in the same manner. By the same logic as the coin game, after 10 years one of those "shrewd investors" beat the index 10 years in a row ... by throwing a dart.
According to the Chartered Financial Analyst Website, there are currently 90,113 individuals that hold the CFA designation. These are the people that manage portfolios and are well trained in what they do. If they all build portfolios in the game above, 88 will beat the market 10 years in a row, and one will be expected to beat the index for 16 consecutive years.
The existance of investors that outperform the market is not a sufficient reason to dismiss the efficient market hypothesis. As just shown, even with efficient markets, given a big enough pool, it is possible to beat the market entirely by luck.
Next time we look at the meaning of "beating the market".
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)