Search This Blog

Tuesday, March 4, 2014

Economics for Cheerleaders

With the Super Bowl finished (yeah Seahawks!) media attention has switched from the teams and players to the cheerleaders. A couple of recent articles caught our attention and, of course, we just couldn’t resist the temptation to comment. 

ABC News is reporting that a Cincinnati Bengal Cheerleader is suing the team over what she claims is a $2.85 per hour wage. The NY Daily News, meanwhile, published an article about the Oakland Raiderettes suing their team for similar reasons. While we don’t claim to know a lot about cheerleading, we do know a lot about economics and the way markets work. Given that, we feel it necessary to warn the cheerleaders that brought these suits to beware of the law of unintended consequences.

We checked a few of the NFL websites and found that the pay wasn’t all that great, and most had a very strict contract. These are not working conditions that we would be willing to accept, but then, we didn’t apply. A cheerleading squad consists of 30 very fit women, each of whom successfully made it through the audition process and accepted the terms of their contracts. The teams that we looked at admit that these are part-time jobs. No one should expect to make a decent living as a part-time cheerleader. 

That, in itself, suggest that there is some other non-pecuniary benefit to being an NFL cheerleader. Opportunities listed on team websites include modeling, exposure, networking, personal appearances and promotions. Indications are that between 200 and 1000 applicants pay $25 each to apply to be cheerleaders each year. They then attend training seminars just for the privilege of trying out. In economic parlance, there is an excess supply of cheerleaders. Most teams have at least 6 applicants for each available spot. 

If the $2.85/hr. figure claimed in the Bengals lawsuit is accurate, the equilibrium wage rate for cheerleaders is likely close to zero. The exposure, it appears, is sufficient compensation for the duties that they perform. 

What happens if the Raiderette and Ben-Gals are successful in their lawsuits and the NFL is forced to increase he pay of cheerleaders? Unfortunately for the existing cheerleaders, they may lose their jobs. Supply curves are upward sloping. An increase in the wage rate increases the number of people that are willing to work. If there are 200 people applying to be cheerleaders when the rate is a purported $2.85/hr., how many will apply at $7.85, the minimum wage in Ohio? Certainly more than 200. As the wage rate rises, it becomes sensible for professional dancers to audition. Not only does the number of applicants rise, but so too does the quality of the applicant. 

If, and when, the wage rate approaches the equilibrium level, the number of applicants will decrease and the quality of the applicant decreases. This fundamental rule of labour markets applies not only to NFL cheerleaders, but to bank presidents as well.

Friday, February 14, 2014

The Pricing of Wine and Beer

People in Canada are always whining about the price of beer. This is especially true once they compare prices in the U.S., and the vast majority of Canadians live within 200km of the border. The most recent case we’ve found is from a Globe and Mail article dated Dec 20, 2013. 

This provides us with an excellent opportunity to explain how retail prices are determined when firms are not perfectly competitive. The formula: P=MC/(1+1/ɛ) isn’t particularly hard to compute from the profit maximizing rule, but it is sufficiently difficult that it can’t be done with a calculator. Trust us (because it requires calculus) that it is the profit maximizing equation. P is the retail price, MC is the marginal cost of production and ɛ (a negative number) is the price elasticity of demand. It should be apparent that the price of a good rises as its cost of production rises. What is not so obvious is that as ɛ falls in absolute value, P rises. 

The elasticity of demand, ɛ, measures the responsiveness of consumer to changes in price. It is calculated as the percentage change in quantity demanded divided by the percentage change in price. Since people buy less of most things when price goes up, the elasticity is always negative. The more consumers react to price changes, the larger the elasticity number becomes (in absolute value – a bigger negative number). 

When consumers react strongly to price changes, we call the demand “elastic”. When they don’t respond the term is “inelastic”. The demand for a good will tend to be elastic if there are plenty of substitutes available, if the good is not a necessity, if the price is large relative to income, or if consumers have time to react. 

So, back to beer. The Globe news article is looking at the monopoly retailer of beer in Ontario: The Beer Store. There aren’t many good substitutes for beer, and there are no substitutes when it comes to purchasing beer in Ontario. The demand for beer in Ontario is likely to be relatively inelastic. Compare that to most places in the U.S. where beer can be purchased at Walmart, 7-Eleven and the local gas station. More places to buy beer means higher elasticity and lower retail prices. The price difference between Ontario and Quebec, where beer is available in convenience stores and grocery stores is 27%. It is safe to assume that the production costs are the same in the two provinces, so the price difference is caused by differences in elasticity. It shouldn’t be a surprise that the Beer Store rejects this claim and blames the differences on taxes.  

The major beer brands; Canadian, Kokanee, Blue, all have similar tastes (at least after the first couple). Craft beers, on the other hand, have very different flavours but their price is still limited by the availability of the major brands. Wine, on the other hand, is not easily substituted. A Merlot is not a substitute for a Riesling. A Beaujolais is not a Burgundy. In an article from Yahoo! Travel dated Sep 24, 2013, the author takes us through all kinds of reasons why wine is so expensive. The one reason that they miss is because restaurants can mark it up that much. A consumer that walks into a wine store and doesn’t like the price can choose not to purchase the wine and shop at a different location. A consumer in a restaurant cannot say to a waiter “excuse me while I go next door to the wine store and get a bottle for 40% of what you’re charging”. Once a consumer has entered a restaurant the demand for wine has become very inelastic and, because of that, the price can go up.

The demand for beer and wine tend to be relatively inelastic and elasticity falls as competition falls. That’s why we pay so much for beer and wine in Canada. 

(It’s also why red roses were so expensive today – Feb 14 – but we’ll save that one for next year)

Saturday, January 11, 2014

On Coffee and Climate Change


Whether one accepts or rejects the hypothesis of anthropogenic climate change, evidences does suggest that our planet is going through yet another warming cycle.

Climatologists warn of dire consequences; global food shortages, flooding and other apocalyptic events. Such is the case of a LiveScience article, reposted on Yahoo News, that predicts that I may now be directly affected. It turns out that the coffee crop in Costa Rica is suffering from the higher temperatures.

Coffee is my life blood and I would have to take the climatologists seriously if I hadn’t been trained to observe and interpret human behavior. Economists, you see, study what people actually do, not what they should do, or what we would like them to do.

For example, climatologists warn that the polar ice caps will melt and result in increased ocean levels. One estimate I found suggests that the rise could be as much as 2 meters (6.5 ft) by the year 2100 (National Geographic). That’s about 91 mm per year (0.9 in).

Spanish Banks, Vancouver BC
Spanish Banks, a beautiful beach near the University of British Columbia, regularly has tide changes of 3.6 m (12 ft.) in a 7 hour period. That means that the water can move out by 400 meters (1/4 mile) at low tide. In the summer, families can be seen playing near the water’s edge at low tide. Children build sand castles in the wet sand.

When the tide comes in, the water level rises by a half meter (20 inches) every hour. Surprisingly, no one ever drowns. Even the children eventually realize that their fortresses are doomed and move to higher ground. Observation of human behavior suggests that, as the oceans rise, some people will build dykes to protect the property, and eventually, all will move to higher ground. This is not going to be a costless exercise, but it will happen.

The same basic human behavior will determine the price of my coffee. It may be that Peter Lehrer, author of the LiveScience article, loses his coffee plantation as temperatures rise but economics suggests that coffee prices won’t rise. As the article states, land that is higher up on the mountain and currently too cold for coffee, may become farmable. Enterprising coffee growers, reacting to price changes will plant coffee at higher altitudes. As the planet warms, it will be possible to grow coffee further from the equator, and the market mechanism suggests that people will plant there as well.

Mr. Lehrer will be incurring costs from global warming disproportionately when compared to others on the planet, but that is a topic for another blog.

Climate change will cause changes in where and how we live. The transition is going to be expensive and is going to happen when is it no longer prudent to maintain the status quo. I, for one, am going to buy some ocean front property … in Houston.

 

Monday, January 6, 2014

Why We Can’t Predict Interest Rates

An article in the Financial Post has impugned me honour and the honour of other fine economists (thanks Capt. Barbossa for the verbiage).The basis of the negative press has to do with the inability to accurately predict future interest rates. I thought, therefore, that I would take this opportunity to defend my colleagues and explain why forecasting some economic variables is so difficult. In particular, I want to look at interest rates.
First, let’s be clear that there are several different interest rates. The money market rate is the rate charged on overnight loans between financial institutions. This is the rate that the Bank of Canada uses as its policy instrument. As of Jan 2, 2014, this rate was 1%. The Bank uses this interest rate to influence economic activity and the inflation rate.
The bank rate is the interest rate the central bank charges for overnight loans to major financial institutions. The bank rate is always 25 basis points above the target overnight rate. (1 basis point = 1/100th of 1%) When the target rate is 1%, the bank rate is 1.25%.
The prime rate is the interest rate that banks charge their best customers for short term loans. Since our banks can borrow as much money as they want from the Bank of Canada, the prime rate is closely linked to the bank rate.
The long term bond rate is the rate received for lending to government and corporations. Bond rates differ due to credit worthiness and by the length of the loan (maturity). Generally, the longer the maturity, the higher the interest rate will be. It is this interest rate that influences private business investment and the residential mortgage market.
Long term interest rates are determined by the demand and supply of loanable funds, or equivalently, the demand and supply of bonds. Central banks don’t have direct control on these rates but they can influence through open market sales and purchases of bonds with different maturities. This is what the US Fed is doing with its quantitative easing program.
To accurately predict short term interest rates we look to the Bank of Canada’s objectives and their policy tools. The Bank’s objective is to keep the inflation rate, as measured by the change in the core CPI, at 2% per year. They have an ‘operational guide’ of 2% plus or minus 1%. That is, they want to keep the inflation rate between 1% and 3% per year.
When economic activity; consumer spending, construction, exports etc. decreases, unemployment tends to rise and the inflation rate tends to fall. In response to this, the Bank lowers the target rate to encourage investment spending. When the economy expands too rapidly, the inflation rate rises, and the Bank raises the target rate to down the rate of expansion.
When will inflation rates rise? Not an easy question to answer. In the last several years the potential output of the economy has been growing faster than actual spending. Inflation increases when the economy gets close to capacity. A core inflation rate of 1.1% indicates that the Canadian economy is not operating at close to capacity. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics reports US inflation at 1.7% indicating that our biggest trading partner is also operating below capacity. Inflation.eu reports inflation rates of 2.09% in Great Britain, 1.34% in Germany, 0.68% in France, 0.23% in Spain and 0.66% in Italy. With little inflationary pressure in any of our other major trading partners, interest rates are not likely to increase there either.

So, when will interest rates rise? Not anytime soon!

Monday, September 23, 2013

Walmart … The Company We Love to Hate

One would think that, with all the people who claim to hate Walmart, they would be out of business by now. Apparently, they are not. For the year ending July 31, 2013, Walmart reported revenues of USD 473 billion. On average, everyone on the planet spent about $80 there last year. Clearly number one on the “hated company” list. See Walmart financial data on Yahoo!.

This blog is not about the evil dragon, it’s about the dragon slayer. In particular, the efforts of the Washington DC city council’s effort to penalize the company for wanting to create 1800 jobs in their city. In early September, the council voted to impose a minimum wage premium of 50% on big-box retailers. This would raise the minimum wage from $8.25 per hour to $12.50 per hour. The increase would be effective immediately for new entrants while existing retailers would have a four-year exemption. See the Reuters article for details.
The rationale of city council, according to Council member Vincent Orange is that “the value of our residents’ time is greater than $8.25. If that is true, I’m out of a job because economic theory is clearly wrong. The supply of labour is determined by the marginal value of leisure time. If the offered wage is greater than the value of leisure, people will sell their time. This follows from the assumption that individuals will act rationally, at least on average. There are people working for the minimum wage in Washington DC and doing so willingly (since slavery was abolished a long time ago). Therefore it is fair to assume that there are some people who value their time at less than $8.50 per hour.
To be clear, they are not happy about it, but that is natural. Work is bad. Play is good. That’s why we require compensation.
Backers of the bill justify the wage hike because “Walmart can afford it”. That is not the issue though. Firms exist to make profits. Without profits they just fade away. Where are Blockbuster, Borders and Kodak? Reducing a company’s profit removes their incentive to create jobs. In the case of Washington DC, Walmart could be at a disadvantage relative to Target since Target gets 4 more years at the existing minimum wage.
If there is a demand for Walmart in the DC area, then the optimal thing for Walmart to do is to build their stores outside the DC area as close as possible to the border. That way, DC residents will be able to enjoy Walmart’s low prices and cities in Virginia and Maryland can enjoy the benefits of the tax revenues.
There is still the possibility that DC Mayor Vincent Gray will veto the bill. Until the issue is resolved, expect Walmart to do nothing. The people that lose in this case are the shoppers in DC and the 1800 people that would have had jobs.

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Shoppers Return and Workers Leave


It’s hard to feel sorry for businesses that don’t react to market changes in a timely manner. We have previously written about firms that couldn’t keep up with changes in consumer tastes (Krispy Kreme), or to changes in technology (Kodak, Borders, Best Buy). This story is a little different because in involves the effect of consumer demand on labour markets.
A recent Bloomberg News report that we first saw on Yahoo! News confirmed by our own observations, tells about the vast empty spaces on Walmart shelves. Unlike firms that are on the verge of bankruptcy and can’t afford to purchase additional merchandise, Walmart’s problems are caused by large numbers of consumers. Walmart has plenty of stock, it’s just hidden away in the back of the stores. Walmart has a labour problem.
When the economy collapsed after the financial crisis, household incomes fell and consumers spent less. A decline in consumption means less revenue for firms. When revenues decline, firms have to reduce their costs, typically by laying off workers. During the height of the recession in 2009-10, the unemployment rate hit 8.7% in Canada and 9.7% in the US.
When there is an excess supply, there is downward pressure on prices. Unemployment is an excess supply of labour and, during the recession, there was downward pressure on wages. Walmart was able to capitalize on this, not by ‘screwing workers’ as on commentator in the article put it, but by taking advantage of market prices.
As with all previous economic downturns, the post-crisis recession eventually ended. Consumer spending started to increase and the demand for labour recovered. Unemployment started to fall and there was upward pressure on wages. Walmart didn’t react. Target and Costco apparently did.
If Target raises wages and Walmart does not, we should expect workers to leave Walmart to work for Target. Staffing levels rise at Target and fall at Walmart. Customer service at Walmart falls because they don’t have enough cashiers and store shelves stay empty because they can’t hire workers to restock them.
The same commentator that accused Walmark of screwing workers also claims that workers that are treated better are more productive. This may not be entirely accurate. Workers at Target have to be more productive than workers at Walmart to keep their jobs. The premium that Target pays their workers prevents them from shirking their responsibilities. A worker that loses their job at Target is forced to go back to work for Walmart. This is the efficiency wage argument made by Alchian and Demsetz in their 1972 paper published in the American Economic Review.
The market for labour is not that much different from any other commodity. When demand falls, price falls and when demand rises, price rises. In an effort to keep costs down in a recovering economy, Walmart management has found themselves with a shortage of workers and with employees that are less productive than employees at their competitors.

Tuesday, May 28, 2013

The Faucet is Leaking … Call the Electrician!


In 1692 when the Pilgrims left London bound for Halifax aboard the Niña, the Pinta and the Santa Maria, they brought with them 100 head of dairy cattle. By 1776, when Canada separated from England to become the 51st state, the dairy cattle roamed wild over most of the prairies.
There is a very good reason that economists don’t comment on history – it is not our field of expertise.
One must wonder, then, how accurate an op-ed piece that appeared in the Vancouver Province could be. The piece was a critique of a Fraser Institute study on milk marketing boards. It was, however, written by a historian.
In his effort to critique, our historian has made two errors that are common to any first year student. The first is the difference between ‘cost’ and ‘price’. The second is the difference between ‘demand’ and ‘quantity demanded’.
‘Cost’ refers to the market value of all of the inputs used in the production of a product. ‘Price’ is how much a consumer pays for the product, and is based on the consumer’s perceived value. When price exceeds cost, the producer earns a profit. Price can be determined either through a market system or by direct government control. Minimum wages are an example of government controlled pricing.
‘Quantity demanded’ is how much consumers will purchase at a particular price. ‘Demand’ is the relation between quantity demanded and ALL possible prices. The definitions of ‘quantity supplied’ and Supply are similar; referring to the amount that firms are willing to sell. Quantity supplied can equal quantity demanded, but supply can never equal demand. This many sound like semantics, but it is the key to understanding how markets actually function.
In his op-ed piece, Professor Muirhead states that, under supply management, “domestic demand is matched with domestic supply”.  Disregarding the aforementioned error in terminology, equating quantity demanded and quantity supplied is exactly what the market mechanism does through changes in price. When government determines the maximum amount that can be produced, the market still determines the price. Thus, comparing the price of milk between supply management and market determined is not like comparing apples to oranges.  It’s comparing milk to milk.
The key element missing from the article is the side effect of supply management. To restrict the quantity produced, and thus increase price, governments issue quotas, or licenses to produce. Because the restricted supply raises the price of milk, more farmers would like to enter the dairy industry. They can’t, however, without obtaining a quota. If there is a demand for the quotas, and there is a limited supply, then the quotas themselves have value. Each time a Canadian buys milk or cheese they contribute to the profitability of these quotas. In a study done several years ago, the single largest cost of dairy producers was the acquisition of the quota.
Getting rid of supply management and compensating the existing producers for the value of their quotas would almost certainly reduce milk and cheese prices. With some notable exceptions, free markets are always more efficient than government intervention. Milk markets are not one of these exceptions.
Need more evidence? Ask the Venezuelans about toilet paper.


Thanks to my colleague JM for bringing this article to my attention.

Thursday, February 28, 2013

When ‘Money’ isn’t really ‘Money’

Since the financial collapse of 2007-2008 there has been a rapid increase in the U.S. monetary base and plenty of discussion about the impending hyperinflation. This is more prevalent in the U.S. than in Canada due to structural differences in our banking systems, but that would take more than 500 words to explain.

Today’s objective is to explain Mike Moffat’s recent article in the Globe and Mail. First, some definitions: Hyperinflation is a period of rapid, broad-based price increases, normally defined as inflation in excess of 50% per month. The monetary base is the liability of the central bank. This typically consists of issued currency plus reserve deposits of commercial banks. The money supply (M2) consists of currency in circulation (in the hands of the non-bank public) plus chequing and savings accounts at commercial banks and credit unions plus money market mutual funds. M2 is ‘money’ as a medium of exchange.
The Quantity Theory of Money tells us that there is a relationship between the money supply and prices. More specifically; the inflation rate will be equal to the growth rate of the money supply minus the growth rate of real GDP (gross domestic product).
The journalists and commentators that are predicting hyperinflation as a result of the Fed’s loose monetary policy are confusing the money supply with the monetary base. To maintain liquidity in the commercial banks, the Fed has been purchasing money market instruments – short term treasury bills and commercial paper off the market and paying for them with newly created reserve deposits. This action causes an increase in the monetary base. The commercial banks lost billions in the financial collapse and are still fighting liquidity problems. As a result, they have been increasing their reserves. When banks hold reserves and don’t lend them out, the monetary base increases, but the money supply does not. Inflation is caused by an increase in the money supply, not the monetary base. Until banks start lending these reserves, there is very little threat of inflation.
The Globe and Mail article suggests that the markets understand this even if the journalists don’t. The Fisher equation tells us that the nominal interest (the interest rate measured in dollars) is approximately equal to the real interest rate (purchasing power) plus the expected rate of inflation. Nominal rates for 10-yr treasuries are just under 2% at the time of writing. This implies that money market professionals do not expect to see inflation in the near future, regardless of what the commentators say.
At a dinner hosted by the Boston Fed last May, it was apparent that officials in the US are aware of the buildup in reserves and do actually have a plan to prevent inflation in the event that lending activity increases.
Until then, just remember, the sky is not falling … except in Russia.

Sunday, February 10, 2013

Greg Mankiw on Immigration Policy

I got the idea for writing this blog from Prof. Makiw's blog. When he writes articles, it leaves very little for me to ad. So ... See Greg's commentary in the New York Times on why Economists are generally in favour of liberal immigration policies.

And yes ... I also benefited from immigration, my mother was born in England.

Monday, January 28, 2013

Principles of Agents

Any Introductory Business course will teach you that shareholders are the owners of the firm. The shareholders elect the Board of Directors to oversee the firm on their behalf. The Directors appoint the company President and the other members of the executive team who are responsible for the day-to-day operations. The Directors and executive team are the agents of the principal owners of the company.

Economists have long studied a situation known as the Principal-Agent problem. This inefficiency occurs when the objectives of the principals, the shareholders, differs from the agents, the executives. Finance theory suggests that individual investors want to maximize returns and minimize risk. This implies using the equi-marginal principle to strike a balance between the two.
The Board and executive may have an objective of maximizing their own income or their own power. Agents typically share in profits by way of bonuses, but not in losses. A company that has negative net income does not require the company president to pay back salary or previous bonuses, nor do they encumber future bonuses. This is just one example of how the Principal-Agent problem can manifest itself.

Evidence of the Principal-Agent problem appeared in several places this week. The first, as related in a Reuters article, involves the investment bank Goldman Sachs (GS). There is currently a proposal to split the role of Board Chairman and the role of CEO between two people.  The idea is that the Chairman oversees the activity of the CEO which is a management position. This may prevent the risk taking activity that lead to the banking collapse of 2007-2008. The company, however, has put forward a legal challenge to prevent a vote on the motion. Essentially, the company is using shareholders’ money to the detriment of shareholders.
JP Morgan Chase (JPM) is also fighting a legal battle in an attempt to prevent shareholders from voting on a motion to break up the company. See the American Banker article for the details. The rationale is similar to the Goldman Sachs situation.  JP Morgan has four distinct businesses, some of which are vastly riskier than others. This not only puts the whole company at risk, but affects the optimal pricing of the firm. In the finance world, they refer to the plan to break up the company as “unlocking value”. Again, the company is using shareholders’ money to their detriment.

Perhaps the most troubling revelation this week was something that was not reported. Apple (AAPL) has $136 billion in cash and marketable securities on its balance sheet that it refuses to return to shareholders. (Source: SEC filing) Apple is currently showing Owners’ Equity of $127 billion which means the entire book value of the company, plus some, is being held in cash. The problem with this is that cash earns less than 2% on average. For example, if that money were returned to shareholders they could purchase shares of Altria Group (MO), that currently pays dividends of 5.3%. Returning half of the $127 billion would double Apple’s return on equity without hampering their ability to operate.
Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan and Apple are just three examples of the Principal Agent problem that caught our attention this week. There will be more next week and the week after that. We can’t help but wonder if the Principal-Agent problem would exist if agents had principles.
 

Tuesday, January 22, 2013

Sticky Buns and Sticky Wages

One explanation often found in textbooks for the relatively slow pace of price adjustment in the macroeconomy is ‘sticky wages’. The idea is that, due to long term contracts and other structural impediments, firms cannot reduce wages when the demand for their product falls. 

Microeconomic theory tells us that firms will hire workers up to the point where the marginal product of labour is equal to the real wage rate. When the demand for a firm’s product falls, the price of their product falls and the real wage rises. In order to restore the cost minimizing solution, firms must either cut nominal wages or increase the marginal product. Increasing marginal product of labour requires using less labour. So firms must cut jobs or cut wages. Both of these can prove difficult to accomplish in the short run. 

This is the unfortunate circumstance that Hostess Brands was facing late last year. A Reuters article in the Montreal Gazette tells of the demise of the Twinkie. As people have become more health conscious the demand for the 150 calorie high-fat snack has decreased. At the same time, droughts and agriculture policy have increased the price of the flour used to produce the Twinkies. Both of these circumstances have led to a decrease in the production of Twinkies, and Hostess was faced with either laying off employees or reducing wages. 

Faced with a staggering 300 different labour contracts, the company had no success in reducing wages. The article quotes one baker as saying he would rather be unemployed than take a wage cut. This is consistent with an upward sloping labour supply curve. With no opportunity to cut labour costs and no control over flour prices, Hostess decided that the only way to preserve its cash was to shut down production. This is what our theory suggests will happen if price falls below the average variable cost of production.  

Hostess has now filed for bankruptcy protection in the United States and has ceased production of the infamous Twinkie. While Hostess could not profitably produce Twinkies, it may be possible for another company, with lower labour costs, to do so. Hostess still owns the rights to the Twinkie and is currently seeking a buyer for the recipe and brand name. If and when the Twinkie returns to the US, there is no doubt that it will be manufactured and shipped by workers with lower wages than those that worked at Hostess. 

Sticky wages in the sticky bun business. Result: unemployment.

Tuesday, January 15, 2013

Hunting: Market Style


Teddy Roosevelt was credited by the NY Times recently as saying that ‘wildlife belongs to all, and not just to those with land and wealth’. Of course Mr. Roosevelt was president of the United States from 1901 to 1909 when the population was around 90 million and there were only 46 states (New Mexico and Arizona joined in 1912 and Alaska and Hawaii in 1959). In Mr. Roosevelt’s time, wildlife was not terribly scarce.
Now, with 50 states, 320 million people and an estimated 223 million firearms held by individuals, there is not enough wildlife for everyone to shoot. When a shortage occurs, the most efficient allocation method usually involves a market.
This is the approach that Utah has taken. Some licenses are available for $35 in a blind draw, the method used in most jurisdictions. The supply of licenses is determined to conserve wildlife which, for most species means there will be an excess demand.
Some of the licenses are given to non-profit organizations that support conservation. These licenses are auctioned off to the highest bidder; and that will be the market equilibrium. Still others are given to private land owners willing to open their land to hunters. These tend to be the most expensive licenses. Landowners that participate in this program have a profit incentive to create an environment that is conducive to the survival of wildlife. As such, the likelihood of ‘bagging’ an animal is higher on private land and thus the price is higher. This further increases the incentive for land owners.
The primary objection to this profit-maximizing program is that ‘money’ is being used to determine who gets to hunt. This is true, but it is also a tried and true method of allocating scarce resources in an efficient manner. When a resource is scarce, efficiency dictates that it should be used I the most ‘valuable’ endeavor.
One may argue that wildlife is a social resource, as President Roosevelt did, and this implies that hunting should maximize ‘social welfare’. I’ll admit that I am not a hunter, but as a member of the society that ‘owns’ an elk, I would hope that that elk would be ‘sold’ for the highest possible price.
The NY Times article quotes a dentist from Utah that is complaining about the market allocation of game. We can’t help but wonder if the dentist uses something other than the price mechanism to allocate his services. Perhaps he treats patients for a nominal fee and then schedules his appointments by lottery. Somehow, we doubt that.

Friday, November 23, 2012

New posting on the Pearson site regarding the fiscal cliff.

Tuesday, November 20, 2012

Is an Increase in Demand is “Price Gouging” ?


Keeping with the recent theme of price adjustments, or lack of them, today we are looking at one of the expected results of hurricane Sandy. An article on Yahoo! Finance’s ‘The Daily Ticker’ suggests that retailers in the Northeast United States were ‘gouging’ customers trying to purchase gas, water, food and batteries ahead of the hurricane.
The confluence of Hurricane Sandy and a strong nor’easter (as they are known) was predicted to create a massive storm over the densely populated regions of the US North East. These predictions started a week to 10 days before the storm actually hit. Hurricane force winds reek havoc with power lines and widespread power outages were expected. Hurricanes also cause storm surges, abnormally high water levels and big waves. Flooding was expected in all coastal areas.
The 50 million people that faced the potential for flooding and power outages all went to try and purchase emergency supplies at the same time. The demand for these items increased. The free market reaction to an increase in demand is an increase in price. If prices don’t rise, shortages will occur. See our previous posts on bacon and disposable diapers. This increase in price is not ‘gouging’, it is a natural reaction to an increase in demand.
In several areas there are laws against price gouging by retailers during a disaster. For example, in New Jersey prices are not permitted to rise by more than 10%. North and South Carolina both have similar laws. The general argument is that consumers should not be ‘ripped off’. But, as I teach my students, demand is defined as how much consumers are willing and able to purchase at every price. When a storm is approaching, their willingness to purchase increases – they are willing to pay more. Politicians call it gouging, economists call it equilibrium pricing.
If effective ‘price gouging’ laws are in effect, the amount that consumers are willing to purchase will be greater than what firms have available for sale and there will be a shortage. Some lucky customers will be able to purchase some batteries, or water, then stand outside the store and when the store runs out, the lucky ones will be able to sell their batteries and water at higher prices. (Sounds like ticket scalping for sporting events and concerts, doesn’t it?). The reality is that the equilibrium price must rise. The only question is who is going to benefit, the store owners, or the battery scalpers.

Tuesday, November 13, 2012

Lies, Damn Lies, and Medical Research




According to a recent finding published in the New England journal of Medicine and reported by Reuters, eating more chocolate increases the likelihood of winning a Nobel Prize. With the amount that I consume, I expect to be receive mine in the near future.

I’m not holding my breath however, since the study, at least as reported, has made some obvious errors in their use of statistical methods and the interpretation of the results. (Though perhaps it was intended to be facetious) The author of the study plotted the number of Nobel prizes per capita against consumption of chocolate per capita. What he found was that they appeared to form a line. A simple regression showed that the relationship was positive with a probability of error (that there was no relationship) equal to 1/10,000. Compelling evidence to be sure, until one delves into the world of statistical analysis.

The underlying theory behind the relationship between chocolate and Nobel Prizes has to do with the effects of flavonoids (whatever they are) on cognitive abilities. The more chocolate (or wine) consumed, the higher is cognitive function and this increases the probability of being awarded the Nobel Prize. There is no indication, however, that the Nobel Prize winners ever consumed chocolate. Nor did the study consider those that did consume chocolate and did not win the Nobel Prize. Forrest Gump comes to mind.

Without doing any analysis of my own, I suspect that chocolate consumption per capita is correlated with Nobel Prize winners per capita, but there is no causal relationship. There is likely a causal link between chocolate consumption and income, as chocolate is a normal good. This could be confirmed by finding, or determining the income elasticity of demand for chocolate. Alternatively, one could regress chocolate per capita against GDP per capita (PPP estimates) and the GINI index – to control for income distributions. The coefficient on income should be positive and I suspect the coefficient on the GINI Index to be negative if significant.

Next, run a regression of average education or literacy rates as a proxy for education, against income per capita; again, checking the effect of income distribution. Since education is a normal good, the coefficient on income should be positive. This shows correlation, not causation. Higher income leads to higher spending on education and higher education leads to higher income.

Finally, regress average education or literacy rates against Nobel Prize winners. More education leads to more research. More research leads to more Nobel Prizes.

The relationship observed between chocolate consumption and Nobel Prizes likely has very little, if anything to do with chocolate consumption. There is a causal relationship between income and both education and chocolate consumption. Thus, there is a correlation between chocolate consumption and education and therefore, between chocolate and Nobel Prizes.

Consider this an open invitation for any reader to undertake the proposed research. Perhaps the New England Journal of Medicine will publish it.

Thursday, October 11, 2012

The Story CBC Didn’t Get Wrong


We commented this month on two stories about supply shocks that the CBC got wrong. The first was prediction of a bacon shortage, which was subsequently recanted. The second was a prediction of a disposable diaper shortage.
This week, the CBC reported nothing about the start of the annual cocoa harvest in Ivory Coast, where 40% of the world’s chocolate originates. This is a good thing, because the CBC can’t get it wrong if they don’t report it. Fortunately, Reuters’ African branch did file a report. The weather has, apparently, been ideal for the harvest of cocoa beans and that suggests that there will be an increase in supply. Given the CBC’s last two reports, we suspected that they would predict a surplus of chocolate (like that could ever happen). An increase in supply would, initially, cause a surplus but competition among the sellers would quickly drive the price down and get rid of the surplus. This is exactly the opposite case of the bacon and diaper stories where supply decreased and price went up.
Before you go and get all excited about lower chocolate prices, however, we need to explore another Reuters article that explains some misguided government policy. In an effort to protect and/or increase the incomes of Ivory Coast cocoa farmers, the government has imposed a minimum farm-gate price on cocoa. This year’s price has been set at about 9% above last year’s price. The problem with this strategy is that last year’s harvest was unusually poor and the price rose as a result. This year’s abundant harvest should cause prices to fall, not rise.
As every student that has every taken a micro course from me knows, effective price floors always lead to surpluses. In labour markets, minimum wages cause unemployment. In cocoa markets, there will be a surplus of cocoa in Ivory Coast. Not surprisingly, “Farmers said very few buyers were active”.
The price controls in Ivory Coast are good news for Ghana where Bloomberg reports that a lack of rain fall has hurt this year’s crop. The higher farm-gate prices in Ivory Coast increase the demand for cocoa grown in Ghana. The higher prices will partially offset the lower crop yields, and the total effect will depend on the price elasticity of demand – a topic for another day.

Tuesday, October 2, 2012

No bacon shortage … but a diaper shortage is imminent.

The CBC reported today that there will be no bacon shortage as was suggested just last week. The whole bacon shortage has been written off as a pile of hogwash. Apparently, bacon prices are expected to rise which will induce more production and reduce consumption. We certainly wish that we had thought of that (they say tongue-in-cheek).


But CBC also reported today that there will be a shortage of disposable diapers. It seems that there has been a fire in a Japanese plant that produces 20 percent of the world’s acrylic acid which is used to make superabsorbent polymer, a key ingredient in disposable diapers. Supply of diapers will fall and there will be a shortage.

Remember last week when feed prices went up and the supply of bacon fell causing a shortage?

So, once again, you are hearing it here first. There will be no shortage of diapers. A decrease in the supply of acrylic acid will induce the other producers to increase output. The decrease in the supply of diapers will cause diaper prices to rise. Some people will switch to cloth diapers and/or diaper services.

Next week, CBC will announce that the whole diaper shortage scare was nothing but a pile of ****.

Tuesday, September 25, 2012

Automobile Accounting


Stories have been circulating this week about the production costs of the Chevy Volt hybrid automobiles. The numbers are astounding! According to a Reuters article in the National Post story, it costs US$89,000 to produce a car that sells for US$39,995. GM is losing US$40,000 per car. Yet GM continues to produce and market these vehicles. There is something seriously wrong with the management at GM, or there is something wrong with these numbers.

Basic economic theory suggests that a firm will be willing to sell its product for any price greater than the marginal cost of production, provided that the price is higher than the minimum average variable cost. The same economic theory tells us that “sunk costs” are irrelevant for decision making. A sunk cost is a fixed cost that has been incurred that can never be recouped. An example would be research and development costs. These costs certainly effect profits, but not the profit making decisions.

The article referenced above suggests that the $1.2 billion spent by GM should be divided up among the number of Volts that have been sold. While an accountant might agree with this, an economist certainly would not. The R&D money is a sunk cost. It can never be recovered. It reduced profit by $1.2 billion dollars. That money is an investment in a technology that is still developing, and will be used in other models in the future. The patents are intellectual property of GM and could, in theory, be sold to other automobile manufacturers.

The costs that are relevant to the production of the Volt, are the materials, labour and equipment used to produce each vehicle – the marginal costs of production. We haven’t asked GM for their cost figures, and we suspect that the batteries add significant costs over internal combustion engines, but to suggest the marginal cost of producing a Volt is US$89,000 is ridiculous.

Another issue surrounding the Volt, as reported by CBS news, is the lackluster sales of the Volt. GM has recently reduced the price of the volt (increasing the loss per vehicle reported by the industry analysis in the Financial Post article) in an attempt to increase sales. Demand curves are downwards sloping, so a reduction in price should increase the number of vehicles sold. The biggest problem that electric vehicles face is that oil prices, and therefore gasoline prices have fallen. Electric cars are a substitute for gasoline fueled cars, and a drop in the cost of operating a gasoline vehicle reduces the demand for electric cars. On our road trip through the western states this summer, we were able to purchase gasoline for about the equivalent of C$0.90 per litre. At this price, electric cars don’t make economic sense.

At some point in the future, oil prices will be high enough and the technology used in electric cars will be efficient enough that we will see more electric cars on the road. Until then, we’re investing in the oilsands.

Tuesday, September 11, 2012

The Story of Isaac and Joe


On the morning of August 21st of this year, I stumbled out of bed at the Marriott Key Largo Resort and went out on the balcony to drink my morning coffee. (Tough life, I know) I called back in to my niece, who accompanied me on this particular adventure, and told her that a storm must be coming. The wind in the Keys usually blows from the west, but on that particular morning, it was blowing from the south. Later that day we learned that the National Hurricane Center was predicting that Tropical Storm Isaac would strengthen to hurricane force as it crossed the Straits of Florida and would then hit somewhere in the Keys in 5 days. Fortunately, we flew home from Miami on the 23rd and didn’t have to cross “hurricane” off the bucket list.

The euphoria was short lived as the economic impact was felt back home. Not the minor damage in the Keys, or the more substantial damage in Plaquemines Parish LA, but the devastating damage to the Louisiana crabbing fleet. Crab is one of my favourite foods, and I have been known to drive the 275 miles (440 kms) just to get a steamer pot from the closest Joe’s Crab Shack. In Louisiana, they catch mainly Blue crab, and my particular favourite is Dungeness so why, might you ask, will the hurricane have any effect on me.

The supply of Blue crab is down as a result of the hurricane. Boats, docks, coolers and traps have been lost and flooded roads make it impossible to get to those that were not destroyed or damaged. According to a New Orleans Times-Picayune, the current daily catch is 6,000, down from 18,000. This reduction in supply is sure to raise the price of Blue crab. (Sounds like something straight out of Forrest Gump – but that was shrimp, not crab – and I digress.)

Dungeness crab, which is found in the North-Eastern Pacific Ocean off the coast from Northern California to Alaska, is a substitute for Blue crab. As the price of Blue rises, the demand for Dungeness increases. As the demand for Dungeness increases, so does its price. When the price of Dungeness increases, the marginal cost of producing steampots at Joe’s will increase. Joe’s supply curve is dependent on their marginal costs. As Joe’s supply curve shifts left, they may be forced to increase their prices.

That’s where I get hurt. An increase in prices at Joe’s will not stop me from eating at Joe’s, but it will reduce the consumers’ surplus I receive – the difference between the value that I receive and the price that I pay. Consumers’ surplus is what generates my happiness. Higher prices means lower consumers’ surplus which means less happiness. Blame it on Isaac.

Thursday, April 12, 2012

Psst … Senator Dorgan … It’s ALWAYS an issue of supply and demand!

He’s actually the former Democratic Senator from North Dakota, but that doesn’t make the story for Yahoo! Finance’s Daily Ticker any less interesting. The quote in the title of this blog refers to the current price of gasoline – C$1.40/litre in Canada and US$4.00/gal in the US (1 US gallon = 3.8 litres). In the Yahoo! article, former Senator Byron Dorgan is quoted as saying that “(it) is not an issue of supply and demand”.

What Mr. Dorgan probably meant was that the pump price of gasoline is not being determined by the current production and consumption of gasoline. He suggests that the price has been driven up by “excess speculation” in commodity markets. To this end, he is suggesting that regulators “ensure that the price of gasoline reflects the fundamentals of supply and demand”.

Today’s lesson, for Senator Dorgan and politicians everywhere, is about the fundamentals of supply and demand, and the role of speculators.

Part I: Supply depends on the availability of raw materials and the costs of production. When politicians block the construction of pipelines, they increase the cost of moving oil from the point of origin to the refineries. When they ban drilling for oil, they prevent new supplies from holding down prices. When they don’t authorize the construction of new refineries, they prevent supply from increasing.

Part II: Commodity futures markets are all about speculation. Futures markets exist due to the uncertainty of future spot prices. (A spot price refers to the price for immediate delivery). If the price of a commodity was known for certain, there would be no benefit to contracting for future delivery, and all bets on future values would have no payoff. The uncertainty surrounding future prices creates a market for hedging and a market for speculators.

Hedgers buy and sell commodities for future delivery to reduce their risk. Speculators are betting that current spot process and future spot prices will be different and they “bet” accordingly. Without speculators willing to take on the risk, hedgers may not be able to reduce their risk.

When prices are expected to rise, current demand will increase, current supply will decrease and current price will rise. If my new sources are even remotely accurate, Iran is enriching uranium in an effort to produce nuclear weapons. Most of the rest of the world condemns Iran and has placed embargos on Iranian oil. Israel wants to blow up Iranian research centers and Iran has threatened to blockade the Straits of Hormuz. A large portion of the world’s oil passes through that body of water.

If Iran closes the Straits, the spot price of oil will certainly rise. Since there is a positive probability of that happening, expected prices for crude oil in the future are rising. Higher future oil prices cause higher current oil prices. Higher crude prices mean higher gasoline prices.

Part III: For speculators to make a profit, they have to be correct on average. If the price of oil is not going to rise, speculating that it will rise results in losses. Speculators cannot, by themselves, drive up spot prices and keep them there long enough to liquidate their positions. Anyone that doubts that should ask the Hunt Brothers who tried to corner the silver market in the late 1970’s and watched their fortune evaporate in 1980.

Gasoline prices are high because demand has been increasing faster than supply. More cars, more planes, more electricity, fewer drilling permits, no new pipeline, no new refineries. Oil prices are rising due to uncertainty in the Gulf. It’s all about supply and demand.