Search This Blog

Sunday, October 31, 2010

Proposition 19 and the price of peppers in BC

Proposition 19 is the ballot initiative in California that, if passed, will legalize the possession and cultivation of small amounts of marijuana for personal use. As economists, we get to ignore the ethical and political implications and focus only on the impact on markets. The Globe and Mail published and interesting article on Saturday about the implications for BC (click here for article).

There are some issues in the article that we believe need clarification. The first has to do with the increase in demand and supply of pot in California if Proposition 19 is approved. We agree that the cost of marijuana will fall, but only because of the reduction in risk, not due to economies of scale. Marijuana would still be illegal under the Federal Controlled Substances Act and thus, large scale facilities are not likely to emerge due to the threat of federal prosecution. There are roughly 37 million people living in California and there aren't enough DEA agents to arrest all users, only commercial growers. The demand for marijuana is not likely to increase if it is legalized. We need only look at the number of people that speed, run red lights, use cellular phone and refuse to buckle up to know that people don't obey laws. If the benefit exceeds the cost, people will break laws. The penalty for possession of small amounts of marijuana is trivial so the risk is not likely to change. The price of marijuana will almost certainly decrease (depending on the tax) and usage may increase.

Secondly, the author makes some claims about the economic effects on BC. There will be no reduction in BC's GDP, only because the marijuana trade is illegal and not included in GDP in the first place. Likewise, the people employed in the marijuana industry do not show up on Statistics Canada employment numbers and those wouldn't change either. The article implicitly assumes that all marijuana cultivated in BC is shipped to California. The US has a population of 310 million. (On a recent trip to Florida, I was golfing with some gentlemen from Baltimore. When the learned I was from BC, they commented that we grew great bud ... I don't think they meant beer)

If, and when marijuana is legalized in California, BC would stand to benefit by also legalizing the cultivation of marijuana. We have several greenhouses that currently grow bell peppers that retail at $1.99/lb. Enterprising  greenhouse owners would remove those crops and replace them with marijuana. That would be the short term response. The long term response would be the construction of more greenhouses and an expansion of the industry, taking advantage of the economies of scale. GDP in BC would rise (now legal) as would the tax revenue of the provincial government.

The downside is that with the removal of the pepper crops, bell pepper prices would rise in BC.

Thursday, October 28, 2010

Two out of three ain't bad

Economists are a strange bunch to be sure. You just never know what we are going to research. We are currently working on a paper that attempts to explain why college business instructors, and economics instructors in general, don't often serve on committees and don't rise to administrative positions. The topic for the next Economists Cafe at our institution is "Why duelling was an efficient way to solve disputes" presented by a colleague from SFU.

Today, however, the Globe and Mail reported on a working paper that caused us to shake our heads. Three Ontario based economists have written a paper on what characteristics affect the salary of university professors. (Click here for article) The usual suspects are present: rank (professor, associate, assistant), experience, age, sex, field (yes, economists are among the top earners) and quality of university. But the most unusual attribute ... number of chili peppers on Rate My Professor. (click here for working paper)

The results? Top earners are hot, male, economists.

Thursday, October 21, 2010

Income Inequality: Too many causes to ignore

A recent article in the New York Times tackled the issue of income inequality and suggested that it had been growing over time and that it was now "too big to be ignored". (Click here for article)

We will acknowledge that income inequality has been increasing throughout the world. What we take exception to is the following paragraph:

"Yet many economists are reluctant to confront rising income inequality directly, saying that whether this trend is good or bad requires a value judgment that is best left to philosophers. But that disclaimer rings hollow. Economics, after all, was founded by moral philosophers, and links between the disciplines remain strong. So economists are well positioned to address this question, and the answer is very clear. "

First, there are many causes of income inequality. While all men (and women) are created equal ... that is only under the law ... not in economics. We all have different endowments. Some are tall, some are fast, some are intelligent, some are born into wealth, some are lucky. Income equality would first require equality at birth.

Second, not everyone has the same tastes. Personally, I greatly value my leisure time, so I am on the backward bending portion of my labour supply curve. Steve Jobs apparently has a labour supply curve that is always positively sloped. Surprise!! He earns more than I do. Income equality would require that everyone has the same tastes and behaves in exactly the same way.

What is unfair is to suggest that Steve Jobs should pay higher taxes to support me, just because we view leisure diffferently.

Third, welfare measures used to create income equality on a moral basis often rely on the assumption of diminishing marginal utility. And by that argument, the utility lost from a $10,000 decrease in income when income is at $2 million is less than the gain in utility from a $10,000 gain in income when income is $10,000. And therefore, society is better off when we take $10,000 from a rich person and give it to a poor person. The problem with this argument that, while it is true that a person values $10,000 more when they have $10,000 than when they have $2,000,000, we have no way of examining utility ACROSS individuals. No one, to my knowledge, has ever suggested that utility functions are cardinal, only ordinal. We can say that individual A gets more utility from two hotdogs than one, but we cannot say that A gets more utility from hotdogs than person B.

Redistribution of income always makes one person worse off. In that sense it cannot be a Pareto improvement, and that is the way most economists measure the welfare effects of social policy. And that is the reason we leave it to philosophers to argue the point.

Wednesday, October 20, 2010

Chinese Auto Market

A recent Business Day article outlines overcapacity concerns in the Chinese car manufacturing industry. Sales have boomed as China’s auto market overtook the U.S in 2009 as the world’s largest due to the emerging middle class and rapid increase in per capita incomes. The demand for cars far exceeds supply at the moment.

This year, up to 17 million vehicles are expected to be sold – an increase of 25-30% after last year’s 46% surge. This has caused manufacturers to increase production at a rapid pace, leaving analysts seriously concerned. The auto market has huge potential in China, a country with a massive population but relatively low percentage of car ownership.

The article reports that international joint ventures do not hold enough current capacity to meet the huge demand, resulting in new investment decisions.
Nissan, Toyota, Hyundai, Volkswagen and FAW to name but a few, have recently announced openings of new production facilities in mainland China. This increase in the supply-side capacity of the car industry seems to be at risk of too much inward investment.

Some concerns of the National Development and Reform Commission, China’s powerful economic planning agency claims:

“Serious overproduction capacity will lead to negative market competitiveness, a loss in enterprise efficiency, factory stoppages and other problems.”

Perhaps this should serve as a reminder of elasticity of supply in a rapidly growing sector. As a general rule for the resposniveness of producers to changes in the price of their goods, if prices rise then so does supply. But we know that cars are a normal good. So long as your income is rising, you will purchase more. Which leads to our next point...

Forecasting is difficult in the auto industry and adding new plants takes time. Our readers will recall a previous blog on the devaluation of the yuan (see below). We would like to point out that just last week The People's Bank of China said it was raising benchmark rates by 25 basis points in an effort to curb persistent inflation. An increase in the interest rate is designed to slow investment. The Business Day article is evidence of this inflation. We could likely be seeing too much capacity in a few years when markets have cooled.

For more on the People's Bank click here.

Thursday, October 14, 2010

The Wok Calling the Kettle Black

We have previously blogged on the dispute between China and the rest of the world regarding the pegged value of the yuan. In short, China refuses to let the yuan rise to it's equilibrium value. By keeping their currency artificially low, they encourage exports and discourage imports. The U.S. has tried to get China to abandon this policy to no avail. In the last month, the Federal Reserve in the U.S. has undertaken a policy of quantitative easing - increasing the money supply. The result is a decline in the value of the US dollar against most other currencies and gold prices hitting record highs (in US dollars).

You can't blame us for being a little surprised that China would actually criticize the US for actively depreciating the dollar given that the yuan has been undervalued for years. (Click here for article) China argues that the quantitative easing will lead to inflation and upward pressure on the yuan. The only way that China can maintain the relative price advantage is to continuously purchase the US dollar and issue yuan. The result of this action, as we previously explained, is inflation in China.

The depreciation is starting to spread. Brazil, Indonesia and Japan have already started to impliment policies to lower their currencies. Looks like we may have a race to the bottom. The first one with a valueless currency wins.

Rolling back to recession

A little macroeconomic lesson from the chief thinkers at Walmart.

An article from Time magazine online edition dated Oct 5 (click here for article) indicates that Walmart will reduce its Rollback program in an attempt to increase sales revenue. During the recession, Walmart had reduced prices in an attempt to increase sales. Why didn’t the discounts help, and why the change in policy?

During a recession, disposable income falls and consumption in general falls. Demand for normal goods decreases and sales fall. That is something Walmart can’t fix, but they may not have known it. There is an information problem when using macroeconomic data to make microeconomic decisions. While Walmart surely knew that its same store sales were down, they had no way of knowing, in real time, whether the decline in sales was due to a decline in GDP or whether customers were shopping at their competitors. The government statistical agencies typically take months to produce accurate macro data, and it wasn’t likely that Target and Fred Meyer were sharing their sales figures with Walmart.

Since Walmart can’t fight the recession all on their own, they did what they could, they dropped prices trying to get customers back in the door. The customers, however, did know that the recession was the reason they were not shopping. Because of that, consumers stalked up on the 40 oz bottle of ketchup and the 50 oz bottle of Tide. The demand for these products is inelastic meaning that consumers don’t use more when prices fall, and total expenditure falls as price falls. When consumers expect prices to rise, as they will after a temporary sale, they will buy at the low price. This just shifts the pattern of spending, not the total spending.

Abandoning this plan, Walmart is now raising prices. Paradoxically, that will increase sales revenue, unless of course, Target and Fred Meyer drop their prices.

Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Drought in Kazakhstan, steak prices rise in Vancouver

In our principles classes we try and show the interdependencies of different markets in different countries. We know it happens, but journalists aren’t normally cooperative in giving us articles we need to demonstrate this ... until this week.

An October 11 article from the Globe and Mail (click here for article) and an October 12 article from the NY Times (click here for article) provide just the kind of obscure relationship that we’ve been looking for.

The story starts with a catastrophic drought in Russia, Ukraine and Kazakhstan, countries that normally grow a large amount of wheat. As the supply of wheat falls, the price of wheat will rise. Since corn is a substitute for wheat, the demand for corn then begins to rise. Shift the focus 6,500 miles west to the American Corn Belt where there was too much heat and too much rain. The weather in the USA reduced the supply of corn. Go another 6,500 miles west and we find that China has been importing American corn. The increase in demand from China and the increase in demand due to the increase in wheat prices together with the decrease in supply from the weather have caused corn prices to rise.

Now turn around and head 7,000 miles west to Texas where they raise cattle. Corn is used as feed stock and, since corn prices are rising, the cost of raising cattle rises. The supply of beef decreases and beef prices rise, including the price of steak in Vancouver.

Next, we`ll head 1,300 miles north to Saskatoon, where they produce potash. Potash is used in the production of fertilizer. When the price of corn increases, the quantity supplied increases. Farmers try and grow more corn. They do this by planting in areas less suitable and use more fertilizer. The demand for fertilizer is a derived demand – derived from the demand for corn. The demand for fertilizer rises and the demand for potash rises. Therefore the price of potash rises.

As potash prices rise, the profits of potash producing companies, such as the Potash Corporation will rise. If profits are expected to continue to rise, and/or the firm is not maximizing profits, they may become a takeover target. Another firm may attempt to purchase most or all of the outstanding shares of the company.

That brings us to the last stop on our trip, 9,000 miles southwest from Regina to Melbourne Australia, the home of BHP Billiton. BHP has recognized the upside potential for potash and has made an unsolicited $38.6 billion hostile bid for Potash Corp.

Our story is complete. From the wheat fields of Kazakhstan, 30,000 miles to the corporate offices of BHP Billiton we have seen the interdependence of markets.