Search This Blog

Friday, October 8, 2010

Ireland Update

Ratings agency Fitch cut Ireland's credit worthiness Wednesday, downgrading it to A+ from its previous AA- rating follows a similar move earlier this week by rival agency Moody's.
However, both Moody's and Standard & Poor's still rate Ireland at the higher grade of AA2 and AA-, respectively.

This had an immediate negative impact on Ireland's borrowing costs on international bond markets. The interest rate, or yield, that investors demand to buy Ireland's 10-year bonds rose to 6.4% Wednesday.

Next month Ireland will publish a 4 year deficit plan and will then unveil a 2011 budget that reduces debt by at least 4 billion euros, which could depress Ireland's already deflated economy.

“The downgrade of Ireland reflects the exceptional and greater-than-expected fiscal cost associated with the government's recapitalization of the Irish banks, especially Anglo Irish Bank,” said Chris Pryce, director of Fitch's government debt group. “The negative outlook reflects the uncertainty regarding the timing and strength of economic recovery and medium-term fiscal consolidation effort.”

But Fitch said Ireland has enough cash stockpiled (more than 34 billion eruos, including its national pension reserves) and borrowing capacity to ride through the crisis, with full funding for government spending already secured through mid-2011. Excluding the bank bailout costs this year, Ireland's 2010 deficit is projected to reach 11.9 per cent, “a more appropriate measure of the underlying fiscal position.”

To read the full story, click here for the article.

Wednesday, October 6, 2010

Principal Agent Problem - or what we should now call the Jerome Kerviel Problem

Jerome Kerviel , ex-trader for Société Générale, was found guilty and convicted in what is now history’s biggest rogue trading scandal. Breach of trust, forgery and entering false data into computers all linked to covering huge stock bets, he was sentenced to at least 3 years in prison and must pay his former employer damages of 4.9 billion Euros. That was not a typo.
His illicit stock bets are estimated to have cost France’s 2nd largest bank about 5 billion Euros in losses.

Let’s take a look at a quote from the article in yahoo news;

“Kerviel maintained that the bank and his bosses tolerated his massive risk-taking as long as it made money - a claim the bank strongly denied.”

This is an example of the principal agent problem. The principals (bank) hire an agent (Kerviel) to perform tasks on their behalf but they cannot ensure that the agent performs them in exactly the way the principals would like. The actions and decisions of the agent are impossible or very expensive to monitor and the agent and the principal may have differing incentives.

This lack of information was a costly failure of information and bank office controls and systems. It was reported that Kerviel had taken speculative positions on selected stocks without the knowledge of the bank. Société Générale has already been fined four million Euros after admitting to lax financial controls.

It is also reported that “The bank says Kerviel made bets of up to 50 billion Euros - more than the bank's total market value - on futures contracts on three European equity indices, and that he masked the size of his bets by recording fictitious offsetting transactions.”

The principal agent problem stems in part from a separation of principal from agent, where the agent (trader) acts in their own self-interest, not in support of the aims of the principal (bank), the incentive problem we listed above. Much has been published and written in recent years about the incentives to cheat.

Typically, the incentive to cheat is greatest when given the chance to “play” with other people’s money (no real sense of ownership leads to risk loving). The Kerviel case shows just how risky this can be for huge financial organizations if there is a failure of control over the trading floors.

It was calculated that, based on his current salary of 2 300 Euros a month as a computer consultant, it would take Kerviel 177, 536 years to pay off his damages. Spokeswoman Caroline Guillaumin called the verdict "an important ruling that acknowledges the moral and financial harm done to the bank and its staff."

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

More on Fiscal Policy

There are just too many stories to ignore, so once again we blog on fiscal policy. Our previous blogs were a story on the Quebec City arena, and examples of stimulus spending in the U.S.


Today we want to look at infrastructure spending in general and a baseball stadium in particular. Our first article comes from the St. Petersburg Times and looks at the benefits of the spring league to the state of Florida. (Click here for article) The article quotes a study undertaken by The Bonn Marketing Research Group that suggests the economic benefit to the State is $752.3 million annually. (Click here for study) This has prompted government spending to maintain, or increase the number of MLB teams that hold spring training in Florida. The alternate destination is Arizona. In the article, Professor Philip Porter from the University of South Florida is quoted as saying that the study is flawed – having used inappropriate methodology. We have to agree with Prof. Porter. The study looked at benefits, but not costs. This is definitely a shoddy way to do economic analysis. We look at net benefits, not gross benefits.

That brings us to our second article, taken from Bloomberg. (Click here for article) This one deals with the decision by Lee County officials to borrow $81.2 million to build a training center outside of Fort Myers, Florida for the Boston Red Sox and the Minnesota Twins. In this case, an economic analysis could be undertaken. Not all the relevant numbers are presented in the article so some research would be required. To decide whether the County has an economic case for building the stadium, we would look at the capital cost and the annual operating costs of the stadium and compare that to the benefits derived from the stadium, including lease revenues, concession and parking revenues as well as the benefits to the community. All values would have to be discounted to take account for the time value of money. This is known as net present value analysis and is similar to what a profit maximizing firm would do. The difference between public and private analysis is the inclusion of external benefits. If the article is accurate and the stadium would account for $41 million in tourist revenue, a legitimate business case might be made.

Our third article comes from the Washington Post. (Click here for article) In this article, the author argues that the U.S. government should borrow $2 trillion (that’s $2,000,000,000,000) and spend it on infrastructure including roads, railroads, runways, water systems, schools and levees. The argument is that there is so much labour and so much material available due the recession and the fact that interest rates are so low, that the costs will never be lower. Once again, the analysis is flawed. Current interest rates are, in fact low. There is no guarantee that they will stay low. Most of the demand for bonds is currently at the short end of the maturity spectrum. This usually happens when rates are expected to rise. The article does say that current government spending needs no cost-benefit analysis and is completely political. Does it not make more sense then, to initiate broad based tax cuts and let individuals decide what is cost effective? Just a thought.

Sunday, October 3, 2010

What Happens in Vegas, Stays in Vegas

At least that's what the rest of the U.S. is hoping.

A New York Times article on the state of the Nevada economy reports that the unemployment rate in Las Vegas is now 14.7 percent, compared with a national average of 9.6%. (Click here for article). In addition, Nevada has led the nation for 44 consecutive months in housing foreclosures.

Nevada has two problems, the first is the downturn in gambling activity in Las Vegas. Gambling is a form of entertainment and, as such, we should expect that demand is very sensitive to changes in income. A 2008 article entitled:

The Income Elasticity of Gross Casino Revenues: Short-Run and Long-Run Estimates by Mark W. Nichols & Mehmet Serkan Tosun

published in the National Tax Journal (Vol. LXI, No.4, Part 1) suggests that the short run income elasticity is about 1.85. What that means is that a 10% drop in income causes a 18.5% drop in gambling expenditures. The two year recession in the U.S. has been particularly deep and widespread and the effect on Vegas has been more severe than the rest of the country. Las Vegas gets a lot of its clientele from nearby California, but California's unemployment rate is 12.4%. Airlines have cut back flights to Las Vegas in an attempt to keep their revenues up, so even though the planes are full, there are fewer of them.

With fewer people gambling in Las Vegas, the casinos and hotels have been laying off staff. This contributes to the unemployment rate. Nevada residents are generally not a large source of income for the casinos, but an increase in the unemployment rate causes a decrease in the demand for housing. This is the second problem. Housing is a derived demand, derived from the number of residents and their incomes. When the economy was expanding, from 2002-2007, construction in Las Vegas was booming. The credit crisis, the reduction in gambling revenue and subsequent layoffs dramatically reduced the demand for housing and therefore the price of housing. As more and more homeowners found themselves under water, the foreclosure rate increased. Median home prices in Las Vegas peaked at $344,900 in April 2006 and currently sit at $129,950.

Las Vegas will recover. People will return. The question is not 'if', but 'when'. In the meantime, if you have never been to Vegas, now is the time. Room rates are cheap, the food is good and there are plenty of shows to see if you don't like to gamble.

Sources:
Employment Development Department, State of California
United States Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics
Housingtracker.net

Ireland’s Economic Crisis

For those in Canada who may not be fully aware of Ireland’s economic crisis, we thought it would be a good idea to blog about what is really going on. The country has been in recession since the second quarter of 2008.

Last Thursday the government shockingly disclosed that the final cost of bailing out the Irish banks could rise to 50 billion Euros ($60 billion) – much more than previously announced. So what could this mean  for the 5 million people who live there? It will cost roughly 10,000 Euros for every man, woman and child, huge amounts of public money will be required. The country will have to undergo major cuts in expenditure along with tax increases. For the time being, the government has promised not to borrow any more money nor will it seek any more emergency funding from international lenders at least until next year.

This all stems from reckless lending by its banks during a boom that ended in 2007, and as property prices fall, is now becoming one of the biggest busts in history. The deficit for this year will be 32% of GDP – 10 times the limit set for member countries of the EU, mainly due to the extra cost of capital for major banks. But unlike some other European economies (Greece), Ireland has acted early to tackle its debt. Greece was on a threshold before it cut public wages and raised taxes. It acted slowly to address its troubles, and only then as a condition of a 110 billion euro ($145 billion) bail-out by the European Union and the IMF.

Ireland did this early on. Markets have not yet rewarded these steps, largely due to its bank struggles. Apart from the money poured into its banking system this year, Irish government bond yields are increasing. The yield on ten-year government bonds neared 7% on September 29th, a record spread of 4.7 percentage points above those of Germany.

These increased bank losses required bail-outs which raised deficits and lead to even more budget cuts. Another shock came when Allied Irish Banks, one of the two largest financial institutions, was practically nationalized with an injection of 3 billion Euros (not to mention the sudden removal of its chairman and managing director last Thursday).

It is also speculated that if bond yields rise further, Ireland and Portugal might have to borrow from the European Financial Stability Facility (EFSF). This probably is not the case.

Reports show that Ireland has raised enough money to finance this year’s borrowing requirement (it will spread the cost of bank bail outs over several years). Portugal is also not as desperate for cash as Greece was in the spring. In the unlikely event that Ireland was forced to borrow from the EFSF, the fund might find it hard to impose conditions harsher than the ones it has volunteered for already. Click here, for an article in the Economist, and for news on further actions Ireland may be taking click here, for an article in the daily mail.

European Financial Stability Facility: €440 billion fund established in June for struggling euro-zone countries.
More information can be found here.

Saturday, October 2, 2010

Greed and the Pharmaceutical Industry

A relative of mine, whom I greatly respect, has a chronic disease and shared his frustrations on facebook. His posting and subsequent comments inspired this blog, and to him it is dedicated.

"...every individual...endeavours as much as he can .. to employ his capital in support of the domestick industry, and so to direct that industry that its produce may be of the greatest value.......and by directing that industry in such a manner as its produce may be of the greatest value, he intends only his own gain, and he is in this, ... led by an invisible hand to promote an end which was no part of his intention."

An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, Adam Smith 1776

Smith's basic premise regarding the workings of a market economy is that decisions are based on personal welfare (greed) and that people respond to incentives. Be clear though, the greed applies to both sides of the transaction.

The pharmaceutical industry is an easy target for those that do not like the results of free markets. A drug company develops a drug that can cure millions of people and then charges enormous sums of money to those people that want the drug. The argument goes something like: "The drug companies are just in business to make a profit off the backs of the sick".

A quick search of the web brought up numerous articles attesting to this. For example:
  • A November 2009 article from BBC regarding a drug for liver cancer. (Click here)
  • A March 2010 article from the Telegraph regading a drug for bone marrow cancer. (Click here)
  • An August 2002 article from New Zealand TV regarding a leukaemia drug (Click here)
Cue the economist, devoid of ethics and a general "caring" for the world at large ... we are a dismal bunch.

Pharmaceutical companies are in business to earn a profit. To that end, they undertake medical research develop new drugs, patent them and submit them to clinical trials. If the clinical trials show sufficient efficacy with tolerable side effects the drug is licensed for sale in a particular jurisdiction. Each different jurisdiction requires its own licencing procedures. A 2003 article in the Journal of Health Economics estimates that the capitalized cost of bringing a drug to market is around $800 million. (Click here)

Why would a firm invest $800 million on a product? To earn a profit. They are greedy. They make no apologies for their greed, nor should they.

So what of those people who think those drugs should be available to them for free? Or at least at a price where the developer doesn't earn profits? Why is it that people want pharmaceuticals? To make their quality of life improve, or to extend the length of their lives, or the lives of loved ones, or a combination thereof. All of these reasons create benefits for the drug user and their families ... they are greedy, they want to increase their well being.

Adam Smith tells us that it is this mutual greed that drives a market economy. People want drugs to make them better and firms will develop those drugs to earn profits. If no one wanted the drug, the firm wouldn't bother to create it.

There is a lot of hypocrisy on the anti-profit side. I have never heard of an accountant, sales rep, biochemist, secretary or fork lift driver offering to work for a pharmaceutical company for free. So why do these same people expect that a pharmaceutical company will do all that work producing drugs for free? These very people, that object to the profit motive, are also among those that sue drug companies when the drugs don't perform exactly as intended. Is that not greed?

Our patent system gives the developer of a drug the exclusive right to produce and sell a drug for a period of 20 years. After that time, other firms may produce and sell the drug. This system encourages the research and development needed to produce new drugs and also ensures that the price of drugs will eventually fall.

Greed is not a bad thing. It is the motivation for decision making. We tend to do what is best for ourselves. Everyone doing this is how a market works. Market economies have their shortcomings, but they are better, by far, than anything else we have tried to date.

Now, I have to go take my medications that are way too expensive!!!

Friday, October 1, 2010

UK Budget Deficit Figures



According to the Office for National Statistics (ONS), new public sector borrowing hit a record £15.9bn for August. This comes after inflation led to a rise in interest payments on index-linked government bonds. Officials claim this is further evidence that the coalition is right to press ahead with cuts. Net debt, relative to GDP, rose to 56.3%. That borrowing figure was about £3bn more than economists expected.

An article in BBC news quotes the latest figures for borrowing in the first 5 months of the financial year reaching £58.1bn. Interest paid out on government debt was close to £4bn in August. This disappointment on the spending side is caused by the retail price index (RPI), being negative a year ago and interest spending being low.

What the article does not mention is that debt interest costs will not deviate much from £70bn under the coalition’s plans, increasing to £66.5bn in 2015-16. In comparison, under labour’s plans, the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) claims it would have reached this level earlier, in 2014-15. That is a lot of money.

Tax revenue is rising, but so is the cost of dealing with the nation’s borrowing. The article notes that the forecast for 2010-11 borrowing as a whole is around £149bn, down from last year's total of £155bn.

The ONS figures leave out the impact of financial intervention by the government, which reduce overall borrowing because of profit contributions from the part-nationalized banks. The rise in the RPI (used to set payments on index-linked bonds), meant interest payments were at £3.8bn, almost three times what they were in August last year and the country’s finances could be out of whack for some time.

But it may be too early in the fiscal year to draw major doom and gloom conclusions. Before this month, borrowing figures had come in lower than expected in 9 of the previous 12 months, with revenues coming in unexpectedly strong.

The bottom line still stands that revenues are usually always weak in August, and so far they are still 9% up on last year, compared to a Treasury forecast of 6.6% growth in 2010-11. If nothing changes, total borrowing this year would still come in several billion below forecast.
And for those suggesting the government’s borrowing will lead the country to bankruptcy, well it is simply not the case and an old saying of ours comes to mind. When pigs fly?

Governments can default on their debt but they can’t go bankrupt. Before the election, the UK still had triple-AAA credit rating, and the market was demanding and interest rate of only 3.9% to lend the government money. For a reference, U.S bonds were 3.7%. Whatever the coalition is facing, it is certainly not bankruptcy or default.

Investors are worried about the huge debt in the financial sector, and of those debts, how many the government will be forced to honour. This ties in to the latest headlines in Ireland, where the government has lost control of it’s balance sheet.

Another article in today’s BBC news gives the latest report on Irelands banking and property crisis. We should be reminded here, that reducing public borrowing is only part of the problem as governments also need to be concerned with what is happening in the private sector. This ties in to the latest headlines in Ireland, where the government has lost control of it’s balance sheet.


Index linked: An investment, where the return rises in line with inflation.

UK National Statistics website found
here.